Four Seasons Hotel Firenze and The St. Regis Florence are both Renaissance palaces from the fifteenth century.
The Four Seasons stands in the largest private garden in Florence, a ten-minute walk from the Duomo, and holds three Michelin Keys. The St. Regis is on the Arno, a short walk from Ponte Vecchio, and has been a hotel since 1866.
Overview
2008, renovated 2024
1866, renovated 2011
3 Michelin Keys
1 Michelin Key
Five stars
Four stars
No. 12 in 2026
—
Quiet
Central
Luxe
Hot-air balloon flights lift from the private botanical park
Luxe
24/7 butler service, Frette-dressed four-poster beds
Heritage
1473 palazzo with original frescoes and mythological friezes
Heritage
15th-century Brunelleschi palazzo on the Arno, restored frescoes
Wellness
Santa Maria Novella botanical rituals, heated 28-meter pool
Classic
Hotel since 1866, royal guests on Piazza Ognissanti
Vibe
Fifteenth-century noble estate across Florence's largest private botanical park
Palazzo grandeur, soaring chandeliers, dusk champagne sabrage ritual
Location
About 1,800 metres apart, roughly 29 minutes on foot.
Quiet
Away from the crowds. Getting around takes intention.
Borgo Pinti beside Giardino della Gherardesca, ten minutes to the Duomo
Central
Well-located: walkable to some things, a short ride to more.
Piazza Ognissanti on the Arno, ten minutes on foot from Ponte Vecchio
Rooms
Four Seasons Hotel Firenze
St. Regis Florence
Silk wall hangings, marble bathrooms, suites with 15th-century ceiling frescoes
Coffered or frescoed ceilings, river-facing balconies over the Arno
Pool
28-meter seasonal outdoor pool in the botanical park
No pool
Spa
Santa Maria Novella remedies, Finnish saunas, Turkish steam baths
Private spa suites with Jacuzzis and hammams, myBlend treatments
Gym
Two-story garden fitness centre with Technogym, park yoga and Pilates
24/7 on-site fitness center
Dining
Michelin-starred Il Palagio, Atrium Bar's vintage Negronis, wood-fired pizza poolside
Atrium Bar
Tuscan dishes at Winter Garden, afternoon tea at Café Ginori
Story
Renovated 2024
Built in 1473 by Bartolomeo Scala, chancellor to the Medici
Renovated 2011
1432 private residence, luxury hotel since 1866, Queen Victoria stayed
Press
3 Michelin Keys
Forbes Five-Star
UK Readers' Choice Awards – Florence
It’s a converted Renaissance-era palazzo… this is what a Florentine luxury hotel ought to be, right down to the frescoed ceilings.
the entire hotel is like a museum with restored frescoes, bas-reliefs, stuccoes and silk wallpaper at every turn.
1 Michelin Key
Forbes Four-Star
US Readers' Choice Awards
A stylish Florentine palazzo originally planned by Brunelleschi, with tastefully furnished and elegant interiors.
Rooms are just as richly decorated as expected — they are grand, gilded, brocaded spaces where your imagination can easily transport you back in time.
Reviews
Notes
Choose the Four Seasons for the garden.
The palazzo of 1473 keeps its frescoes and stands in a botanical park, where there is a 28-metre outdoor pool in season. The restaurant Il Palagio has a Michelin star, and the spa uses products from Santa Maria Novella.
It holds five stars from Forbes and our gold medals for Heritage and Luxe, and ranked 12th in The World's 50 Best Hotels 2026.
Choose The St. Regis for the river.
Rooms with balconies look straight over the Arno, under coffered or frescoed ceilings. Butlers are on call around the clock, and champagne is sabered at dusk each day to a grand piano.
Its usual nightly price is the lower of the two.
Questions
Which has a pool?
The Four Seasons has a 28-metre outdoor pool, open in season, and a heated whirlpool all year. The St. Regis has none.
Where is each one?
The Four Seasons is on Borgo Pinti, a ten-minute walk from the Duomo. The St. Regis is on Piazza Ognissanti by the Arno, a short walk from Ponte Vecchio and the Uffizi.
Which holds more Michelin Keys?
The Four Seasons holds three Michelin Keys and The St. Regis holds one.
Four Seasons Hotel Firenze
St. Regis Florence