The St. Regis New York and The Ritz-Carlton New York, Central Park both hold five stars from Forbes and our gold medal for Luxe.
The St. Regis, on Fifth Avenue since 1904, is the historic one, with a butler for every room and our gold medal for Heritage. The Ritz-Carlton faces Central Park, and the rooms on that side come with a telescope.
Overview
1904, renovated 2026
2002, renovated 2019
—
1 Michelin Key
Five stars
Five stars
Lively
Central
Luxe
Round-the-clock white-glove butlers, Bentley house car rides
Luxe
Dedicated Club Lounge concierges, five daily culinary presentations
Heritage
1904 Beaux-Arts landmark with nineteen-story brass-and-marble staircase
Design
Gilles and Boissier interiors, Carrara marble, custom sketch-inspired carpeting
Classic
Continuous Midtown hospitality since 1904, daily champagne sabering
Wellness
Second-floor La Prairie Spa with caviar facials, thermal steam rooms
Vibe
White-gloved butlers on every floor, Gilded Age traditions
Top-hatted doormen, classic residential retreat across from Central Park
Location
About 450 metres apart, roughly 7 minutes on foot.
Lively
Where things happen: restaurants, shops, people.
Fifth Avenue at 55th Street, four blocks from Central Park
Central
Well-located: walkable to some things, a short ride to more.
Central Park South opposite Artists' Gate, steps from Carnegie Hall
Rooms
St. Regis New York
The Ritz-Carlton New York, Central Park
Jewel-toned velvet, custom surrealist coffee tables, Italian marble bathrooms
Park-facing rooms with telescopes, deep soaking marble baths
Spa
In-room custom massage and bodywork on request
Six private treatment rooms, Swiss cellular rituals, caviar facials
Gym
24-hour fitness center with cardiovascular machines and free weights
Technogym cardio, Peloton bikes, Concept2 rowers, ballet barre
Dining
King Cole Bar under Maxfield Parrish mural, skylit La Maisonette
King Cole Bar
Contour all-day gastro-lounge, Club Lounge five daily culinary presentations
Contour
Story
Renovated 2026
Limestone landmark completed 1904, once Manhattan's tallest building
Renovated 2019
33-story limestone tower, opened 1930 as the Hotel St. Moritz
Press
Michelin Selected
Forbes Five-Star
The renovated interiors, too, stay true to the original Continental style, from the silk drapes to the crystal chandeliers.
Its 171 guest rooms and 67 suites have been reimagined with jewel-tone interiors and gold-tone brass detailing…
1 Michelin Key
Forbes Five-Star
Expect classic bygone-era opulence, with old-school professional service that matches the décor, and a location that’s difficult to top: it’s right on Central Park South...
The sleek stay now boasts a contemporary vibe, more akin to a chic city-center pied-à-terre.
Reviews
Notes
Choose The St. Regis for the Gilded Age.
John Jacob Astor IV founded it in 1904, when it stood as the tallest building in Manhattan. Butlers attend every room and bring coffee in the morning, a Bentley is on call, and champagne is sabered every evening.
Its usual nightly price is the lower of the two.
Choose The Ritz-Carlton for the park.
It stands on Central Park South opposite Artists' Gate, in a limestone tower that opened in 1930 as the Hotel St. Moritz. Park-facing rooms have wide windowsills and telescopes, and the La Prairie Spa has six treatment rooms.
It holds one Michelin Key.
Questions
Where is each one?
The St. Regis is at Fifth Avenue and 55th Street, steps from MoMA. The Ritz-Carlton is on Central Park South, steps from Carnegie Hall.
Which is older?
The St. Regis opened in 1904. The Ritz-Carlton opened in 2002, in a tower built in 1930.
Does either have a pool?
No. The Ritz-Carlton has a La Prairie Spa with steam rooms. The St. Regis offers treatments in the room.
St. Regis New York
The Ritz-Carlton New York, Central Park