The Carlyle and The Mark stand on Madison Avenue on the Upper East Side, each a block from Central Park and Museum Mile, and each holds two Michelin Keys and four stars from Forbes.
The Carlyle is the old institution, with our gold medal for Classic and live jazz every night. The Mark is the fashionable one, with interiors by Jacques Grange and a restaurant by Jean-Georges.
Overview
1930, renovated 2021
1927, renovated 2009
2 Michelin Keys
2 Michelin Keys
Four stars
Four stars
No. 64 in 2025
No. 43 in 2025
Central
Central
Luxe
Pre-war suites, many with working baby grand pianos
Luxe
Round-the-clock Bergdorf Goodman shopping access, John Lobb shoeshines
Classic
1930 Upper East Side landmark, Kennedy's Manhattan base
Design
Jacques Grange interiors, striped marble, custom modernist furnishings
Social
Nightly live jazz at Bemelmans Bar, Café Carlyle cabaret
Local
Striped pedicabs, Central Park picnic hampers, hot dog cart
Vibe
White-glove elevator operators, polished marble hallways
Couture lounge and lobby, artful Upper East Side crowd
Location
About 100 metres apart, roughly 2 minutes on foot.
Central
Well-located: walkable to some things, a short ride to more.
Madison Avenue, one block from Central Park and Museum Mile
Central
Well-located: walkable to some things, a short ride to more.
One block from Central Park and Museum Mile
Rooms
The Carlyle Rosewood Hotel
The Mark Hotel
Black-lacquered paneling, Central Park wallpaper vignettes
Pear-green drapery, sycamore millwork, black-and-white marble bathrooms
Spa
Valmont Spa: Swiss cellular facials, saunas, steam rooms
In-room lymphatic drainage massages, Dr. Barbara Sturm facials
Gym
Modern cardio and strength machines between mirrored pillars
Second-floor 24-hour fitness center with Technogym machines
Dining
Bemelmans Bar murals, Café Carlyle cabaret supper club
Jean-Georges seasonal European-American dishes, Caviar Kaspia bar
The Mark Bar
Story
Renovated 2021
1930 Art Deco tower, John F. Kennedy's Manhattan presidential base
Renovated 2009
1927 Renaissance Revival apartment building, later Art Deco
Press
2 Michelin Keys
Forbes Four-Star
UK Readers' Choice Awards – New York City
The Carlyle Hotel is pure, undiluted essence of old-world Manhattan sophistication, and has been since the days when it was JFK’s “New York White House.”
Tastefully decorated by some of the leading interior designers, including Dorothy Draper, Mark Hampton, Renzo Mongiardino… there’s still a nod to the hotel’s Art Deco beginnings mixed with surprising modern touches.
2 Michelin Keys
Forbes Four-Star
UK Readers' Choice Awards – New York City
The Mark is the very picture of classic, timeless Upper East Side poshness, in spite of — or maybe even because of — its recent, extremely thorough renovation.
The Mark’s interiors — both in the guest rooms and the public spaces — blend classic elegance with modern art.
Reviews
Notes
Choose The Carlyle for old New York.
The Art Deco tower of 1930 was John F. Kennedy's base in Manhattan, and elevator operators in white gloves still work the lifts. There is jazz at Bemelmans every night and cabaret at Café Carlyle, and some suites have a working baby grand piano.
It ranked 64th in The World's 50 Best Hotels 2025.
Choose The Mark for style.
Jacques Grange designed the interiors in striped black and white marble with flashes of orange. Guests can shop Bergdorf Goodman around the clock, take a picnic hamper into Central Park, and ride in the hotel's own striped pedicabs.
It ranked 43rd in The World's 50 Best Hotels 2025.
Questions
How far apart are they?
Both are on Madison Avenue on the Upper East Side, one block from Central Park and Museum Mile.
Which is older?
The Mark's building opened in 1927 as the Hyde Park Hotel. The Carlyle was completed in 1930.
Does either have a pool?
No. The Carlyle has a Valmont spa with saunas and steam rooms. The Mark offers massages and facials in the room.
The Carlyle Rosewood Hotel
The Mark Hotel