Hotel Please
The Menhaden

The Menhaden

Greenport


Design Social Local
Central

Opened 2019   $$$

The Menhaden — vibe

Vibe

A crisp black and white retreat overlooks Front Street, where guests take in Greenport Harbor breezes and watch Shelter Island ferries pass.

“Monochrome maritime outpost”

Design

Crisp black-and-white minimalist interiors with shiplap accents and maritime artifacts honoring Greenport whaling history.

Social

A harbor-view roof deck with firepits, plus a ground-floor cafe and Bunker Bar.

Local

Artwork by Long Island artist Scott Farrell and curated provisions in the ground-floor general store.

Central

On Front Street across from Mitchell Park, steps from the harbor and Shelter Island ferry.

The Menhaden — rooms

Rooms

Minimalist interiors pair clean shiplap accents with deep soaking tubs, walk-in rainfall showers, and complimentary pantries stocked on every floor.

The Menhaden — backstory

Backstory

Built on the former Peconic Hotel grounds, the property honors Greenport seafaring past with reclaimed maritime artifacts and local artwork.

The Menhaden — eat & drink

Eat & drink

Sip cocktails by the firepits on the panoramic roof deck, or grab morning espresso and pastries from the downstairs cafe.

The neighborhood

Mitchell Park sits directly across the street, while village boutiques, seafood spots, and the Shelter Island ferry are steps away.

The app

This is one hotel. The app has every one we rate, in your pocket, for the whole trip.

See what else is nearby, and what’s good in the next city too.
Save it to a wishlist and let whoever you’re going with vote.
Every photo, full screen, the way it was meant to be seen.
Stamp the ones you’ve stayed in. Your passport keeps the record.