The Pridwin Hotel & Cottages
Shelter Island
Vibe
White wicker, lawn games, and saltwater breezes set a nostalgic rhythm across ten waterfront acres overlooking Peconic Bay.
“Nostalgic waterfront hideaway”
Ten waterfront acres with private beach access, moorings, tennis courts, and bayfront swimming pool.
A restored 1927 white clapboard hotel and standalone cottages overlooking Crescent Beach and Peconic Bay.
A Shelter Island institution since 1927, anchored by the multi-generational Wednesday evening waterfront cookouts.
On a hillside overlooking Crescent Beach and Peconic Bay, surrounded by ten acres of waterfront grounds.
Rooms
Main house rooms open onto breezy decks, while standalone hillside cottages feature gas fireplaces, wet bars, and water views.
Wellness
A bayfront pool sits above Crescent Beach, backed by a dedicated spa with a sauna, hammam, tennis courts, and paddleboards.
Backstory
The Petry family has owned this 1927 classic since 1961, partnering with Cape Resorts for an extensive multi-year restoration.
Eat & drink
The Terrace serves local East End seafood over the bay, while the legendary Wednesday night cookouts draw multi-generational crowds.
The app
This is one hotel. The app has every one we rate, in your pocket, for the whole trip.
