Hotel Please
Search hotels & cities Get the app

Where to stay

Bali or Phuket

In short

Bali and Phuket are the two big resort islands of Southeast Asia, and both do pool villas, spas and sunsets very well. The first thing to check is the month, because their seasons are opposite: Bali is dry from April to October, and Phuket from November to April.

After that, Bali is the island with more to it: temples, rice terraces, surf, and several quite different places to stay. Phuket is the better pure beach holiday, with softer sand, calmer water in season and boats out to smaller islands. We list about twice as many hotels on Bali.

Hotels

134

68

Medals

12 gold, 53 silver, 61 bronze

1 gold, 22 silver, 33 bronze

Known for

Design, Luxe, Resort

Resort, Wellness, Luxe

A night

From $20 per night

From $70 per night

In the Michelin Guide

75

33

With a pool

132

68

With a spa

121

59

On the map

What it’s like

Bali

Bali is a Hindu island in Indonesia, and you notice it everywhere: offerings on the pavement each morning, temple gates at every turn, processions that stop the traffic. Inland it’s green and steep, with rice terraces and river gorges. The south coast is surf, cafés and beach clubs.

It’s really several places. Ubud is the jungle town of yoga and art. Canggu and Seminyak are where people eat, shop and go out. Uluwatu is cliffs and surf breaks, and Nusa Dua is a quiet enclave of big resorts on a calm beach.

Phuket

Phuket is Thailand’s largest island, joined to the mainland by a bridge. Its west coast is one sandy bay after another, backed by green hills, and the sea is warm and clear. It’s a place to do very little, very comfortably.

The bays differ. Patong is the loud one, with the nightlife. Kamala and Surin are smaller and calmer, Bang Tao is a long beach lined with resorts, and Mai Khao in the far north is nearly empty. Phuket Old Town, inland, has painted shophouses and the best local food.

Where the hotels are

Bali

Around Ubud, the great ones are strung along the Ayung River gorge: Mandapa, Four Seasons Resort Bali At Sayan, Amandari and Bambu Indah, with Buahan and COMO Shambhala Estate further into the hills.

On the southern peninsula, Bvlgari Resort Bali, Six Senses Bali Uluwatu and Jumeirah Bali are on the cliffs, and Four Seasons Resort Bali At Jimbaran Bay is on the bay below. Desa Potato Head Bali is on the beach at Seminyak, and COMO Uma Canggu and Hotel Tugu Bali are in Canggu.

Phuket

Almost every hotel is a resort on or above a beach. Amanpuri, on a headland of coconut palms above Pansea Beach, holds our gold medal for Luxe. Trisara and Anantara Layan Phuket Resort are on quiet bays to the north of it, and Keemala is in the rainforest above Kamala.

Rosewood Phuket Hotel has its own bay just south of Patong. Banyan Tree Phuket is on the lagoons behind Bang Tao. On the calmer east side are COMO Point Yamu, facing Phang Nga Bay, and Sri Panwa, on the cliffs of Cape Panwa.

When to go and getting around

Each island has an international airport. They’re about three hours apart by air when there’s a direct flight, and most routes change in Singapore, Kuala Lumpur or Bangkok. Neither has trains or much public transport, so you get around by taxi, hired driver or scooter.

Bali

Bali’s dry season is April to October, and July and August are the busiest months. From November to March it rains most days, in heavy bursts. Traffic in the south is slow at any time, so choose one or two bases and don’t try to see the island from one hotel.

Phuket

Phuket’s dry season is November to April, with the best weather from December to March. From May to October it’s wetter, and the west coast gets waves and red flags, though rooms cost much less. The island is smaller than Bali and quicker to cross.

After dark

Bali

Bali’s nights are beach clubs at sunset, then restaurants and bars in Seminyak and Canggu, which have some of the best eating in the region. Ubud and Uluwatu are quiet by ten.

Phuket

Phuket’s nightlife is concentrated in Patong, on and around Bangla Road, which is as loud as anywhere in Thailand. Elsewhere it’s beach clubs at Bang Tao and Kamala, and dinner at the hotel.

Beaches and things to do

Bali

Bali’s beaches are for surfing more than swimming: wide, with strong waves, and dark sand in places. Nusa Dua and Sanur are the calm ones. The days out are the reason to come: temples on cliffs and lakes, rice terraces, waterfalls, a sunrise walk up a volcano, a cooking class in a village.

Phuket

Phuket’s beaches are the better ones for lying on and swimming from, with pale, soft sand and gentle water in the dry season. The best days out are by boat: the limestone towers of Phang Nga Bay, the Phi Phi islands, and the Similan Islands for diving.

By kind of trip

Bali

Phuket

A honeymoon

Bali

Split it between jungle and coast. Capella Ubud is a camp of tents in the forest, and Bvlgari Resort Bali is on a cliff above its own beach.

Phuket

Trisara, where every villa has a pool facing the sea, or The Naka Island, a short boat ride offshore.

With children

Bali

Nusa Dua and Jimbaran have calm water and big resorts. The Mulia Nusa Dua and Ayana Resort Bali both have a lot of pools.

Phuket

Easy, with gentle beaches in season. JW Marriott Phuket Resort & Spa and Dusit Thani Laguna Phuket are set up for families.

Wellness

Bali

Bali’s strongest suit. COMO Shambhala Estate holds our gold medal for Wellness, and Ubud is full of yoga studios.

Phuket

Amatara Welleisure Resort is built around its spa programmes, and Anantara Layan Phuket Resort has a silver medal for Wellness.

Design

Bali

Bambu Indah, built from bamboo and old Javanese houses, and Buahan, which has no walls, both hold gold medals for Design.

Phuket

Keemala, a village of woven pods in the trees, and COMO Point Yamu, both with silver medals for Design.

With friends

Bali

Stay in Seminyak or Canggu. Desa Potato Head Bali holds our gold medal for Social.

Phuket

Stay in or near Patong. Lub d Phuket Patong is a short walk from the beach and Bangla Road.

Peace and quiet

Bali

Amankila, on the far east coast, and Soori Bali, on a black-sand beach to the west, are both well away from the south.

Phuket

The Racha is on its own small island to the south, and Anantara Mai Khao Phuket Villas is on the empty northern beach.

Which to choose

Choose Bali if you want more than a beach: culture, landscape, surf, food and a choice of very different places to stay.

Go between April and October, and stay in two places if you have a week.

Choose Phuket if you want an easy holiday of sand, warm sea and boat trips, with a good resort to come back to.

Go between November and April. It’s the better choice for a winter escape.

Questions

Which is better, Bali or Phuket?

Bali has more variety: temples, rice terraces, surf, yoga and several distinct areas. Phuket has better swimming beaches and island-hopping by boat. For a trip between November and March, Phuket has the weather. From April to October, Bali does.

Is Bali or Phuket better in December?

Phuket. December is the start of its dry season, with sunshine and calm seas. In Bali it’s the wet season, warm but with heavy rain most days. Both are busy and expensive over Christmas and New Year.

Is Bali or Phuket better in July and August?

Bali. It’s the dry season there, sunny and less humid. Phuket is in its monsoon, with rain and rough seas on the west coast, though hotel prices are at their lowest.

Which is better for a honeymoon?

Both are very good. Bali suits a honeymoon in two parts, a jungle villa near Ubud and then the coast. Phuket suits one that’s all beach, perhaps with a few days on a smaller island nearby.

Which is better for a family holiday?

Phuket is slightly easier with small children, for the calm, shallow beaches in the dry season and shorter drives. On Bali, stay in Nusa Dua, Sanur or Jimbaran, where the water is gentle.

Which is cheaper?

They’re close. Food, drivers and private villas tend to cost a little less on Bali. Phuket is cheaper to reach from much of Asia and has strong low-season deals from May to October.

Which has better beaches?

Phuket, for swimming and sunbathing: soft, pale sand and clear water. Bali’s beaches are better for surfing and sunsets, and the best swimming is at Nusa Dua and Sanur.

Which has better nightlife?

Phuket’s Patong is bigger and louder, with Bangla Road at the centre. Bali’s is spread across beach clubs, bars and restaurants in Seminyak and Canggu, and is the better place to eat.

Can you visit both on one trip?

Yes, with ten days or more. A direct flight takes about three hours, and most routes change in Singapore, Kuala Lumpur or Bangkok. Their opposite seasons mean one will have better weather than the other.

How many days do you need?

A week on either is right. On Bali, split it between Ubud and the coast. On Phuket, stay in one place and take a day or two for boat trips.