Buckhead or Midtown
Buckhead and Midtown are the two places most visitors to Atlanta choose between, about six miles apart on Peachtree, the city’s main street. The train links them in ten minutes, and the drive takes fifteen to twenty-five.
Buckhead is the polished one, a district of shopping malls, office towers and big hotels, every one of ours with a pool. Midtown is the arts district, with the museums, the park and streets you can actually walk, and its hotels are a mix of towers and small old buildings.
The St. Regis Atlanta
“Nightly champagne salon”
Waldorf Astoria Atlanta Buckhead
“Neoclassical garden palace”
Nobu Hotel Atlanta
“Quiet Japanese pavilion”
The Whitley, a Luxury Collection Hotel, Atlanta Buckhead
“Southern porch parlour”
Loews Atlanta Hotel
“Hammam lobby hangout”
Four Seasons Hotel Atlanta
“Southern neoclassical palace”
Hotel Granada
“Bohemian courtyard apartments”
Stonehurst Place Bed & Breakfast
“Shingle-style family mansion”
12
11
1 gold, 8 bronze
2 silver, 6 bronze
Design, Luxe, Wellness
Design, Heritage, Wellness
From $100 per night
From $100 per night
8
8
12
5
4
3
On the map
What it’s like
Buckhead
Buckhead is Atlanta’s smart address. It grew up around two enormous shopping malls, Lenox Square and Phipps Plaza, and the streets behind them are lined with some of the grandest houses in the South.
It’s built for cars more than for walking. You’ll find the city’s best-known steakhouses here, the boutiques of Buckhead Village, and the Atlanta History Center, with its gardens and old houses.
Midtown
Midtown is where Atlanta feels most like a city. The High Museum, the symphony and the Fox Theatre are all here, Piedmont Park is the big green space at its edge, and the blocks between are full of restaurants, bars and people on foot.
From the park you can join the BeltLine, an old railway turned walking trail, and follow it past murals and breweries to the food hall at Ponce City Market.
Where the hotels are
Buckhead
Most stand along Peachtree Road beside the malls: Nobu Hotel Atlanta is at Phipps Plaza itself, and The Whitley, Waldorf Astoria Atlanta Buckhead and InterContinental Buckhead Atlanta are within a short walk.
The St. Regis Atlanta is a little apart, across from the boutiques of Buckhead Village, and Kimpton Sylvan Atlanta - Buckhead is on a quieter street nearby.
Midtown
The big ones are on or near Peachtree Street: Four Seasons Hotel Atlanta, Loews Atlanta Hotel and The Starling Atlanta Midtown, all a short walk from the High Museum and the park.
The small ones have more character. Hotel Granada is a 1924 apartment building by the arts centre, and Stonehurst Place Bed & Breakfast is an 1896 house a block from Piedmont Park.
Getting around
The MARTA train runs from the airport through Midtown to Buckhead without a change. It takes about twenty-five minutes to Midtown and thirty-five to Buckhead, and ten minutes between the two.
Buckhead
Around Buckhead you’ll mostly drive or take a car, though the hotels by the malls are a walk from the shops and the train.
Midtown
Midtown is the most walkable part of Atlanta, and it’s closer to the downtown sights. The aquarium, the Coca-Cola museum and the stadium are two or three stops south.
After dark
Buckhead
Buckhead’s evenings are dressed up: steakhouses, hotel bars and lounges. The St. Regis Atlanta opens a bottle of champagne with a sabre every evening.
Midtown
Midtown has more going on: a show at the Fox, rooftop bars, and the bars around Piedmont Avenue, the centre of gay Atlanta. The Starling Atlanta Midtown is next to a food hall, and Loews Atlanta Hotel is in the middle of the restaurants on Peachtree.
Shopping and food
Buckhead
This is the best shopping in the South-east. Lenox Square and Phipps Plaza have every big name between them, and Buckhead Village has the designer boutiques.
Restaurants here are polished and expensive, with a few old Atlanta institutions among them.
Midtown
Midtown is better for eating than for shopping. There are good restaurants at every price along Peachtree and Juniper, and Ponce City Market, a short ride away, has a food hall and shops in an old Sears warehouse.
By kind of trip
Buckhead
Midtown
A first visit
Buckhead
A good choice if shopping and a resort-style hotel are the point. The Whitley is next to both malls.
Midtown
The better base for seeing the city. Kimpton Shane Hotel is two minutes from the train and the High Museum.
With children
Buckhead
Every hotel we list here has a pool. Grand Hyatt Atlanta in Buckhead is one of the larger ones.
Midtown
Closer to the aquarium and to Piedmont Park. Four Seasons Hotel Atlanta and The Starling Atlanta Midtown both have a pool.
On a budget
Buckhead
Kimpton Sylvan Atlanta - Buckhead and Hotel Colee usually cost the least.
Midtown
A special stay
Buckhead
The St. Regis Atlanta, which holds our gold medal for Luxe.
Midtown
Four Seasons Hotel Atlanta, or Stonehurst Place Bed & Breakfast for something small and personal.
Design
Buckhead
Nobu Hotel Atlanta, calm and Japanese, and Hotel Colee, which is the opposite.
Midtown
Hotel Granada, around a courtyard, and Kimpton Shane Hotel.
Which to choose
Choose Buckhead for shopping, a big comfortable hotel and a pool.
It’s calmer and more spread out, and you’ll use a car or the train to see the rest of the city.
Choose Midtown to walk to museums, the park and dinner.
It’s the livelier of the two, it’s closer to the airport and to downtown, and it suits a first visit.
Questions
Is it better to stay in Buckhead or Midtown Atlanta?
Midtown if you want to walk to museums, restaurants and the park, and be close to downtown. Buckhead if you want upscale shopping and a larger hotel with a pool. The train between them takes ten minutes.
How far is Buckhead from Midtown?
About six miles. It’s ten minutes on the MARTA train and fifteen to twenty-five minutes by car, depending on traffic.
Which is more walkable?
Midtown. Its streets are laid out in a grid with restaurants, museums and the park close together. In Buckhead you can walk between the malls and the nearby hotels, and you’ll drive to most other things.
Which is safer?
Both are among the areas visitors use most, and both are busy with people in the evening. As in any large city, take a car late at night instead of walking long distances.
Which is closer to the airport?
Midtown. The MARTA train from the airport reaches it in about twenty-five minutes and Buckhead in about thirty-five, with no change.
Which is closer to downtown and the aquarium?
Midtown, two or three train stops away. From Buckhead it’s about twenty minutes by train.
Which is better for shopping?
Buckhead, by a long way. Lenox Square, Phipps Plaza and Buckhead Village are all there.
Which is better for nightlife?
Midtown, for bars, live music and theatre. Buckhead is better for a steakhouse dinner and a drink in a hotel bar.
Which has hotels with a pool?
Buckhead: every hotel we list there has one. In Midtown, Four Seasons Hotel Atlanta, The Starling Atlanta Midtown, Epicurean Atlanta and Moxy Atlanta Midtown do.
Which is cheaper?
They’re similar. Both are mostly mid-priced, and the most expensive hotel in the city, The St. Regis Atlanta, is in Buckhead.