Cabo or Cancun
Cabo and Cancun are Mexico’s two big beach resorts, on opposite sides of the country. Cabo is at the tip of Baja California, where the desert meets the Pacific. Cancun is on the Caribbean, with white sand, warm turquoise water and jungle behind it.
Cabo is drier, more dramatic to look at and has more top-end hotels, but much of its coast isn’t safe to swim from. Cancun has the better beach, far more all-inclusive resorts, and Maya ruins and islands close by. It’s usually the cheaper of the two.
Chileno Bay Resort & Residences, Auberge Collection
“Swimmable coral cove”
Esperanza, Auberge Collection
“Cliffside Baja casitas”
Montage Los Cabos
“Bayfront sandstone estate”
One&Only Palmilla
“Historic seaside hacienda”
NIZUC Resort & Spa
“Mayan modernist estate”
Le Blanc Spa Resort Cancun
“Greco-Roman beachfront estate”
Grand Fiesta Americana Coral Beach Cancún All Inclusive Spa & Resort
“Hydrotherapy lagoon oasis”
SHA Mexico
“Double-helix longevity clinic”
36
21
7 gold, 17 silver, 12 bronze
2 gold, 10 silver, 9 bronze
Luxe, Resort, Wellness
Resort, Wellness, Luxe
From $200 per night
From $150 per night
22
3
36
21
34
20
On the map
What it’s like
Cabo
Los Cabos is two towns and the twenty miles of coast between them. Cabo San Lucas is the lively one, with a marina, the rock arch at Land’s End and the party. San José del Cabo is the older and calmer one, with a mission church, galleries and good restaurants.
The landscape is desert: cactus, granite and a very blue sea, with sunshine nearly every day of the year. It feels closer to Arizona than to the tropics.
Cancun
Cancun was built for holidays. Its Hotel Zone is a long, thin strip of sand between the Caribbean and a lagoon, lined with resorts from end to end. The sea is warm, clear and the colour of a swimming pool.
It’s green, flat and humid, and it’s the gateway to the Yucatán: Maya cities, swimming holes in the limestone, and the Riviera Maya running south.
Where the hotels are
Cabo
The best are along the Tourist Corridor between the two towns, each on its own cove. Seven hold our gold medal for Luxe, among them One&Only Palmilla, Las Ventanas al Paraiso, Montage Los Cabos and Chileno Bay.
Waldorf Astoria Los Cabos Pedregal is on the Pacific side of Cabo San Lucas, reached through a tunnel in the rock. Zadun is in the dunes near San José, and Four Seasons Resort Los Cabos at Costa Palmas is an hour north on the quiet East Cape.
Cancun
Most are in the Hotel Zone. NIZUC Resort & Spa, at its quiet southern tip, holds our gold medal for Luxe. Le Blanc Spa Resort Cancun, Kempinski Hotel Cancún and JW Marriott Cancun Resort & Spa are on the main beach.
The newer ones are north of the city at Costa Mujeres, on an emptier stretch of sand facing Isla Mujeres: Atelier Playa Mujeres, SLS Playa Mujeres and SHA Mexico, which holds our gold medal for Wellness.
When to go and getting there
Both have big international airports with direct flights from across the United States and Canada. The busiest and most expensive time for both is from Christmas to Easter.
Cabo
Cabo is closest to the west of the United States, about two and a half hours from Los Angeles. It’s dry and sunny from November to June, with whales offshore from December to April. August to October is hot, and September is the month when storms are most likely.
Cancun
Cancun is closest to the east and the middle of the United States, and has more flights than anywhere else in Mexico. December to April is dry and warm. June to November is hotter and wetter, with a chance of hurricanes, most of all in September and October.
After dark
Cabo
Cabo San Lucas has the nightlife, in the bars and clubs around the marina and the beach clubs of Medano Beach. San José is the place for dinner, and for the gallery walk on Thursday evenings in season.
Cancun
Cancun’s Hotel Zone has some of the biggest clubs in Mexico, clustered at Punta Cancun. Away from them, the evening happens inside the resorts, which is where most guests eat and drink.
Beaches and things to do
Cabo
Many of Cabo’s beaches have strong currents and are for walking, not swimming. The swimmable ones are Medano Beach in town and the coves at Chileno, Santa María and Palmilla. What Cabo does best is on the water: whale watching, sport fishing, snorkelling and sailing out to the arch. There’s a lot of very good golf.
Cancun
Cancun’s beach is the reason to come: miles of soft white sand and warm water you can swim in almost anywhere. The days out are just as good. Chichén Itzá and Tulum, the cenotes, snorkelling on the reef, and the ferry to Isla Mujeres are all within reach.
By kind of trip
Cabo
Cancun
A honeymoon
Cabo
Las Ventanas al Paraiso and Esperanza, on bluffs above two coves.
Cancun
NIZUC Resort & Spa, on a nature reserve by the reef, or Le Blanc Spa Resort Cancun, which is for adults only.
With children
Cabo
Pick a hotel on a swimmable cove. Chileno Bay and Four Seasons Resort Cabo Del Sol both have one.
Cancun
The easier choice, for the calm, warm sea. Grand Fiesta Americana Coral Beach is on the sheltered northern shore.
All-inclusive
Cabo
There are fewer, and they’re good. Grand Velas Los Cabos and Le Blanc Los Cabos both have silver medals for Luxe.
Cancun
This is where the idea took off. Atelier Playa Mujeres, TRS Coral Hotel and Hyatt Ziva Cancun are three.
With friends
Cabo
Stay in or near Cabo San Lucas. ME Cabo is on Medano Beach, and The Cape looks across at the arch.
Cancun
Stay at Punta Cancun, near the clubs. Live Aqua Cancún is in the middle of the Hotel Zone, and SLS Cancun is by the marina.
Wellness
Cabo
Waldorf Astoria Los Cabos Pedregal and Park Hyatt Cabo Del Sol both have silver medals for Wellness.
Cancun
SHA Mexico is a medical wellness clinic on the beach at Costa Mujeres.
Somewhere quieter
Cabo
The East Cape, an hour north. Four Seasons Resort Los Cabos at Costa Palmas and Amanvari are there. Or stay in town at Tropicana Los Cabos, in the old centre of San José.
Cancun
Costa Mujeres, north of the city. The St. Regis Costa Mujeres Resort is between the mangroves and the sea.
Which to choose
Choose Cabo for desert scenery, reliable sun, whales, golf and some of the best resorts in Mexico.
It suits couples and groups of friends, and anyone flying from the west coast.
Choose Cancun for the Caribbean beach, an all-inclusive, and days out to ruins, cenotes and islands.
It suits families and first trips to Mexico, and anyone flying from the east coast.
Questions
Is Cabo or Cancun better?
Cancun has the better beach, warmer water, more all-inclusive resorts and more to see nearby. Cabo has drier weather, more dramatic scenery, better top-end hotels and whale watching. Flight time often decides it: Cabo is nearer the west of North America and Cancun the east.
Is Cabo or Cancun better in December?
Both are in their best season. Cabo is dry and sunny with cooler evenings and sea, and the whales have arrived. Cancun is warmer, in and out of the water. Both are busy and expensive over the holidays.
Is Cabo or Cancun better in February?
February is peak season for both. It’s the best month for whale watching in Cabo, where the sea is cool for swimming. Cancun has warm water and dry weather. Book early for either.
Is Cabo or Cancun better in October?
Late October is good in Cabo: the storm season is ending and the sea is at its warmest. Cancun is still in its rainy season in October, with the lowest prices of the year.
Which is cheaper?
Cancun, usually. It has far more hotels, more competition among all-inclusive resorts and more flights. Cabo has fewer rooms and a higher share of expensive ones.
Which is better for all-inclusive?
Cancun. All-inclusive is the standard way to stay there, at every level. Cabo has a smaller number, and many of its best hotels charge for meals separately.
Which is better for families?
Cancun, for the calm, warm, swimmable sea and the choice of family resorts. Cabo works well too if you choose a hotel on a protected cove or with big pools.
Can you swim in the sea in Cabo?
In some places. Medano Beach, Chileno Bay, Santa María Bay and Palmilla are safe for swimming. Many other beaches, above all on the Pacific side, have strong currents and are marked as unsafe.
Which is safer?
Both resort areas receive millions of visitors a year, and the hotel zones of each are well policed. Check your government’s current travel advice for Baja California Sur and Quintana Roo before you go, and take the usual care at night.
Which is better for a bachelorette or a group trip?
Cabo San Lucas is the favourite for groups, with beach clubs on Medano Beach, boats to hire and bars close together around the marina. Cancun has bigger nightclubs and more all-inclusive resorts for adults only.