Sultanahmet or Karakoy
Sultanahmet and Karakoy face each other across the Golden Horn, the inlet that divides old Istanbul from the newer city. A tram crosses the bridge between them in about ten minutes.
Sultanahmet is the historic heart, with Hagia Sophia and the Blue Mosque at the door and a handful of hotels in old Ottoman buildings. Karakoy, with Galata on the hill above it, is the old port turned creative quarter, livelier at night, with more hotels and more places to eat and drink.
Four Seasons Hotel Istanbul At Sultanahmet
“Converted Ottoman prison”
Hagia Sofia Mansions Istanbul, Curio Collection by Hilton
“Ottoman wooden mansions”
AJWA Sultanahmet
“Hand-knotted Ottoman palace”
Catch Sultanahmet
“Restored Ottoman mansions”
The Peninsula Istanbul
“Former passenger terminal”
The Bank Hotel Istanbul
“Converted Ottoman bank”
Ecole St. Pierre Hotel
“Converted French schoolhouse”
L'Union Han Istanbul, Vignette Collection by IHG
“Ottoman insurance landmark”
6
11
1 gold, 1 silver, 3 bronze
1 gold, 4 silver, 6 bronze
Heritage, Design, Luxe
Heritage, Design, Luxe
From $200 per night
From $150 per night
5
6
3
2
4
7
On the map
What it’s like
Sultanahmet
Sultanahmet is where the emperors and sultans ruled from. Hagia Sophia, the Blue Mosque, Topkapi Palace and the underground cistern are all within a few minutes’ walk of each other, around a long park that was once the Roman racetrack.
It’s busy with visitors by day and quiet at night, when the monuments are floodlit and the streets empty. Most restaurants here cater to tourists, and there are few bars.
Karakoy
Karakoy was the city’s port and banking district, and its grand old office buildings now hold cafes, galleries and hotels. The waterfront has been rebuilt as a promenade with a museum of modern art, and ferries leave from the pier for the Asian side.
Climb the hill and you’re in Galata, a tangle of steep lanes under a medieval tower, and beyond that is Istiklal, the city’s main pedestrian street. This side of the water stays up late.
Where the hotels are
Sultanahmet
Four Seasons Hotel Istanbul At Sultanahmet is in a former Ottoman prison between Hagia Sophia and the Blue Mosque. Hagia Sofia Mansions is a row of wooden houses on a cobbled lane against the palace wall.
Hotel Ibrahim Pasha is on a quiet street beside the old racetrack, and Catch Sultanahmet is down the hill, facing the sea.
Karakoy
The Peninsula Istanbul stretches along the waterfront in the old passenger terminal. A street back, The Bank Hotel Istanbul and DeCamondo Galata are in buildings from the days when this was the empire’s banking street.
Up in Galata, Ecole St. Pierre Hotel is a former French school just below the tower.
Getting around
The T1 tram runs between Karakoy and Sultanahmet in about ten minutes, four stops. You can also walk across the Galata Bridge, past the fishermen, in half an hour. The main airport is forty-five minutes to an hour away by car.
Sultanahmet
In Sultanahmet the great sights are on foot, and so are the Grand Bazaar and the Spice Bazaar, a ten or fifteen-minute walk downhill.
Karakoy
From Karakoy you can take a ferry to the Asian side or up the Bosphorus, walk up to the Galata Tower, and ride an old underground funicular to Istiklal.
After dark
Sultanahmet
Evenings here are for a rooftop terrace, with the domes lit up and the sea beyond. It’s peaceful, and for anything livelier you’ll cross the water.
Karakoy
Karakoy’s lanes fill with people at cafe tables in the evening, and the cocktail bars and restaurants are some of the best in the city. The nightlife of Beyoglu is a short walk up the hill.
Shopping and food
Sultanahmet
The Grand Bazaar and the Spice Bazaar are the shopping here: carpets, lamps, ceramics, Turkish delight. For food, walk a few streets away from the main square for better and cheaper kebabs and meze.
Karakoy
Karakoy has the city’s most famous baklava shop, fish sandwiches by the bridge, third-wave coffee and some of its most interesting restaurants. The shops are small design and fashion boutiques.
By kind of trip
Sultanahmet
Karakoy
A first visit
Sultanahmet
Stay here to see the monuments early, before the crowds. AJWA Sultanahmet is a short walk from the Blue Mosque.
Karakoy
Stay here for better evenings, and take the tram to the sights. 10 Karakoy is steps from the waterfront.
With children
Sultanahmet
Flat, walkable and full of things to see. Hagia Sofia Mansions has a pool.
Karakoy
The Peninsula Istanbul has pools and a long waterfront to walk.
On a budget
Sultanahmet
Hotel Ibrahim Pasha and Amiral Palace Boutique Hotel are small and reasonably priced.
Karakoy
A special stay
Sultanahmet
Four Seasons Hotel Istanbul At Sultanahmet, which holds our gold medal for Luxe.
Karakoy
The Peninsula Istanbul, which holds our gold medal for Luxe too.
Old buildings
Sultanahmet
Hagia Sofia Mansions and Catch Sultanahmet, both in restored Ottoman houses.
Karakoy
The Bank Hotel Istanbul and Ecole St. Pierre Hotel, both with silver medals for Heritage.
Which to choose
Choose Sultanahmet to wake up beside Hagia Sophia.
It suits a short first visit and anyone who wants quiet nights. You’ll cross the water for the best food and nightlife.
Choose Karakoy for cafes, restaurants, the waterfront and the ferries.
It suits a longer stay or a return visit, and the monuments are ten minutes away by tram.
Questions
Is it better to stay in Sultanahmet or Karakoy?
Sultanahmet if the historic sights are the reason for the trip and you like quiet evenings. Karakoy if you want better restaurants, cafes and nightlife, with the sights a short tram ride away.
How far is Karakoy from Sultanahmet?
About two and a half kilometres. The T1 tram takes around ten minutes, and the walk over the Galata Bridge takes half an hour.
Is Sultanahmet too touristy to stay in?
It’s the most visited part of Istanbul, and its restaurants and shops are aimed at visitors. The reward is having Hagia Sophia and the Blue Mosque to yourself early in the morning and after dark.
Which is better for a first visit to Istanbul?
Sultanahmet for two or three nights, when the monuments are the priority. Karakoy for a longer stay, when you’ll want more variety in the evenings.
Which is better for nightlife?
Karakoy. Its own bars and restaurants are busy until late, and Beyoglu’s nightlife is just up the hill. Sultanahmet is very quiet at night.
Where is Galata?
Galata is the hillside neighbourhood directly above Karakoy, around the Galata Tower. The two run into each other, and hotels in either are a few minutes’ walk apart.
Which is closer to the Grand Bazaar?
Sultanahmet, ten or fifteen minutes on foot. From Karakoy, take the tram to Beyazit, about fifteen minutes.
Which is better for a Bosphorus cruise?
Both are close. The public ferries and most cruises leave from Eminonu, at the old-city end of the Galata Bridge, a short walk from Karakoy and a tram ride from Sultanahmet.
Which is cheaper?
They’re similar. Each has one very expensive hotel and several small mid-priced ones.
How do I get there from the airport?
By car in forty-five minutes to an hour, depending on traffic. Many streets in Sultanahmet are narrow or closed to cars, so you may walk the last stretch.