Lake Como or Lake Garda
Lake Como and Lake Garda are the two best-known Italian lakes, about two hours apart by car across the north of the country. Como is the narrow, steep, glamorous one, an hour from Milan. Garda is the big one, nearly three times the size, between Milan and Venice.
Como is for villas, gardens and doing things slowly, and it suits couples. Garda has more to do: beaches, castles, wine country, theme parks and mountains at its northern end, and it suits families and active trips. We list about the same number of hotels on each.
Villa d'Este
“Renaissance cardinal's palazzo”
Mandarin Oriental, Lago di Como
“Nine-villa botanical estate”
Passalacqua
“Operatic lakeside villa”
Grand Hotel Tremezzo
“Floating-pool lakeside palace”
Grand Hotel a Villa Feltrinelli
“Carved-timber lakeside villa”
Hotel Lido Palace
“Lakeside Liberty palace”
Lefay Resort & SPA Lago di Garda
“Terraced wellness estate”
Monastero Arx Vivendi
“Walled Garda monastery”
20
18
3 gold, 7 silver, 10 bronze
1 gold, 9 silver, 8 bronze
Heritage, Luxe, Design
Wellness, Design, Luxe
From $150 per night
From $300 per night
16
16
16
17
18
16
On the map
What it’s like
Lake Como
Lake Como is shaped like an upside-down Y, with mountains dropping straight into deep water and small towns pressed against the shore. For centuries it’s been where rich Milanese built their summer villas, and many are still there, behind cypress trees and boat houses.
The prettiest part is the middle, where the three arms meet and ferries cross between Bellagio, Varenna, Menaggio and Tremezzo. The town of Como is at the southern tip, with a cathedral, a walled old centre and the train to Milan.
Lake Garda
Lake Garda is the largest lake in Italy, and it changes as you go north. The southern end is wide and open like a small sea, with low hills, vineyards and olive groves. The northern end narrows into something like a fjord, with cliffs on both sides and a steady wind.
Each shore has its own towns. Sirmione sits on a thin peninsula in the south with a moated castle and Roman ruins. The west has old resort towns such as Gardone Riviera and Gargnano, and the east has the wine villages of Bardolino and Lazise.
Where the hotels are
Lake Como
Como has some of the grandest hotels in Italy, most in old villas on the water. Villa d’Este at Cernobbio holds our gold medal for Heritage, and Passalacqua at Moltrasio and Mandarin Oriental at Blevio hold gold medals for Luxe. All three are near the Como end.
On the middle of the lake are Grand Hotel Tremezzo, with a pool floating on the water, Grand Hotel Villa Serbelloni at the tip of Bellagio, and Grand Hotel Victoria in Menaggio. Il Sereno Hotel at Torno is the modern one.
Lake Garda
Garda’s hotels are more spread out and more varied. On the quiet western shore are Grand Hotel a Villa Feltrinelli, a lakeside villa in its own park, Grand Hotel Fasano and, high above the water, Lefay Resort & SPA Lago di Garda, which holds our gold medal for Wellness.
At the northern end is Hotel Lido Palace in Riva del Garda. The eastern shore has newer spa hotels in the olive groves, among them Cape of Senses Spa Hideaway and Quellenhof Luxury Resort Lazise, and Villa Cortine has a park of its own on the Sirmione peninsula.
Getting there and around
Milan’s airports serve both lakes. Most lake hotels close for the winter, from about November to March, and the season runs from Easter to October.
Lake Como
Como is the easier one without a car. Trains from Milan reach the town of Como in about forty minutes and Varenna in about an hour, and from there ferries link the mid-lake towns all day. The lakeside road is narrow and slow in summer, so the boat is usually quicker.
Lake Garda
Garda is easier with a car, since the lake is some fifty kilometres long. Trains from Milan, Verona and Venice stop at Desenzano and Peschiera on the southern shore, Verona’s airport is half an hour away, and ferries and buses run up both sides.
In the evening
Lake Como
Como is quiet and a little dressed up. The evening is an aperitivo on a terrace as the light goes, then a long dinner. Bellagio and Como town have a few bars, and that’s about it.
Lake Garda
Garda is livelier, with busy waterfronts in Sirmione, Desenzano, Bardolino and Riva on summer nights. It’s still a lake, not a city: the evening is a walk along the harbour, an ice cream and a glass of the local wine.
Things to do
Lake Como
Visit the villa gardens, above all Villa Carlotta and Villa del Balbianello. Take the ferry from town to town, hire a wooden boat for an afternoon, and walk the old paths above the shore. Swimming is mostly from hotel jetties and lidos, since the lake has few beaches.
Lake Garda
Garda has far more. There are pebble beaches all round the shore, the castle and Roman villa at Sirmione, a cable car up Monte Baldo from Malcesine, windsurfing and climbing in the north, wine tasting in the east, and Gardaland, the biggest theme park in Italy. Verona is half an hour away.
By kind of trip
Lake Como
Lake Garda
A couple
Lake Como
This is the lake for it. Passalacqua is a villa of only a few rooms, with gardens running down to the water.
Lake Garda
Grand Hotel a Villa Feltrinelli, on the quiet west shore, or EALA - My lakeside dream, on the cliff near Limone.
With children
Lake Como
Grand Hotel Tremezzo has three pools and a strip of beach. Filario Hotel & Residences has apartments on the water.
Lake Garda
The better lake for families. Quellenhof Luxury Resort Lazise and Aqualux are both a short drive from Gardaland.
A spa
Lake Como
Grand Hotel Victoria and Mandarin Oriental both have silver medals for Wellness.
Lake Garda
Garda’s speciality. Lefay Resort & SPA Lago di Garda holds our gold medal, and Cape of Senses Spa Hideaway is built around its spa.
A grand old hotel
Lake Como
Villa d’Este, a hotel since 1873, and Grand Hotel Villa Serbelloni, which opened the same year.
Lake Garda
Grand Hotel Fasano, from 1888, and Hotel Lido Palace, from 1899.
Without a car
Lake Como
Hotel Villa Cipressi in Varenna is a walk from the train and the ferry, and Palazzo Albricci Peregrini is inside the old town of Como.
Lake Garda
Hotel Lido Palace is a short walk from the centre of Riva, and Grand Hotel Terme is in the old town of Sirmione.
Design
Lake Como
Il Sereno Hotel and The Lake Como EDITION, both with silver medals for Design.
Lake Garda
Monastero Arx Vivendi, a walled monastery in Arco, has a silver medal for Design.
Which to choose
Choose Lake Como for a few slow, beautiful days of villas, gardens and boats.
It suits couples and anyone coming by train from Milan. Two or three nights is enough to see the middle of the lake.
Choose Lake Garda if you want more to do: beaches, castles, wine, mountains and theme parks.
It suits families and longer stays, and it fits a trip that also takes in Verona or Venice.
Questions
Which is better, Lake Como or Lake Garda?
Lake Como for scenery, villas and a quiet, romantic few days. Lake Garda for variety, beaches, families and outdoor sports. Como is the more dramatic to look at, and Garda has more to fill a week.
Which is bigger?
Lake Garda, by a long way. It’s the largest lake in Italy, about 370 square kilometres. Lake Como is the third largest, at about 146, though it’s the deeper of the two.
How far is Lake Como from Lake Garda?
About 170 kilometres from Como to Sirmione, or around two hours by car. By train it takes two to three hours, changing in Milan. A day trip is possible, but a long one.
Which is better with kids?
Lake Garda. It has beaches, shallow swimming, boat trips, a cable car, and Gardaland and other parks at the south-eastern corner. Como is beautiful but has less for children to do.
Which is better for couples?
Lake Como, for most. The villa hotels, the gardens and the ferries between small towns are made for two. On Garda, the western shore around Gargnano and Gardone Riviera is the romantic part.
Is it better to go in September or October?
September is one of the best months on both lakes, warm and less crowded than August. In October the days are cooler, some ferries run less often and hotels begin to close for winter. Garda’s wine harvest is in full swing.
Can you visit in December?
You can, but most lake hotels and many restaurants are closed. Como town has Christmas lights and a market, and the towns on Garda hold markets too. Stay in a town and expect it to be quiet.
Which is easier to reach from Milan?
Lake Como. The train to Como takes about forty minutes and to Varenna about an hour. Desenzano, on Lake Garda, is about an hour by fast train, but you’ll want a car once you’re there.
Which is cheaper?
Lake Garda, as a rule. It has many more hotels, apartments and campsites at every level. Como has a small number of rooms and a lot of people who want them in summer.
What about Lake Maggiore?
Lake Maggiore, west of Como, is quieter than both, with the Borromean Islands and their palace gardens as its great sight. It’s a good choice if you want Como’s style with fewer people.