Old Montreal or Downtown Montreal
Old Montreal and downtown are neighbours, a fifteen-minute walk or two metro stops apart. One is the old port city of cobblestones and stone warehouses, and the other is the modern centre up the hill.
Old Montreal has nearly twice as many of our hotels, most of them small and set in nineteenth-century buildings. Downtown’s are bigger towers with pools, joined to the shops and the trains by underground passages, which matters more than you’d think in January.
Hotel Nelligan
“Velvet stone warehouses”
Hotel Place d'Armes
“Neoclassical stone landmark”
Hotel William Gray
“Glass-atrium vinyl hangout”
Auberge du Vieux-Port
“Cobblestone warehouse lofts”
Fairmont The Queen Elizabeth
“Peace bed-in landmark”
Hotel Birks Montreal
“Beaux-Arts jewelry landmark”
Hotel Bonaventure Montréal
“Brutalist duck-pond oasis”
Humaniti Hotel Montreal Autograph Collection
“Modernist vertical village”
13
7
6 silver, 6 bronze
6 bronze
Design, Heritage, Local
Design, Wellness, Heritage
From $200 per night
From $200 per night
9
3
2
5
3
6
On the map
What it’s like
Old Montreal
Old Montreal is where the city began, beside the St. Lawrence River. The streets are cobbled, the buildings are grey stone, and with the French signs and the church bells it’s the nearest thing to Europe in North America.
Notre-Dame Basilica is here, with a square in front of it, and so is the Old Port, a long riverside promenade with a big wheel and a skating rink in winter. It fills with visitors by day and is pleasantly quiet late at night.
Downtown Montreal
Downtown is the Montreal of office towers, department stores and hockey. Rue Sainte-Catherine is the main shopping street, the Bell Centre is where the Canadiens play, and Mount Royal, the wooded hill the city is named after, rises just behind.
Under all of it runs the Underground City, miles of passages linking shopping centres, metro stations and hotels, so you can cross the centre in winter without a coat.
Where the hotels are
Old Montreal
Most are in old warehouses and banks. Hotel Nelligan and Le Petit Hotel are on Rue Saint-Paul, the prettiest street, Auberge du Vieux-Port faces the river, and Hotel William Gray opens onto Place Jacques-Cartier, the main square.
Hotel Place d’Armes looks across at the basilica. For somewhere quieter, Hôtel Gault is on a calm side street, in a warehouse with its cast-iron columns intact.
Downtown Montreal
Fairmont The Queen Elizabeth sits on top of the central station, and Hotel Bonaventure Montréal is on the roof of the building next door, around a garden with a pond. Both connect to the Underground City.
Hotel Birks Montreal is in the old Birks jewellery building on Phillips Square, a block from the shops. The grandest hotels in this part of town are a few streets north, in the Golden Square Mile.
Getting around
You can walk between the two in about fifteen minutes, downhill toward the river, or take the metro two stops. The airport is twenty-five to forty minutes away by taxi, depending on traffic.
Old Montreal
Old Montreal is for walking, and the cobbles are hard on wheeled bags. The basilica, the port, the archaeology museum and the restaurants are all within ten minutes of each other.
Downtown Montreal
Downtown has the trains, the metro and the airport bus. The fine arts museum and the path up Mount Royal are a walk away, and the Plateau and Mile End, where Montrealers eat and drink, are a few metro stops north.
After dark
Old Montreal
Old Montreal is at its best in the evening, when the day trippers leave and the restaurants light their candles. It has some of the city’s best dining rooms, and in summer, terraces on the rooftops and along the squares.
Hotel William Gray and Hotel Nelligan both sit in the middle of it.
Downtown Montreal
Downtown is livelier and less pretty: bars on Crescent Street, hockey nights around the Bell Centre, and in summer the big free festivals in the Quartier des Spectacles.
Warwick Le Crystal is steps from the Bell Centre.
Shopping and food
Old Montreal
Rue Saint-Paul has galleries, craft shops and boutiques. Eat here at least once: the neighbourhood has more good restaurants to the block than anywhere else in the city, though you pay for the setting.
Downtown Montreal
Rue Sainte-Catherine and the underground malls are where the city shops. For food, downtown is practical more than special, and the best meals are a short ride away in Old Montreal, Little Burgundy or the Plateau.
By kind of trip
Old Montreal
Downtown Montreal
A first visit
Old Montreal
Stay here for the Montreal on the postcards. Le Petit Hotel is a small hotel in a greystone warehouse on Rue Saint-Paul.
Downtown Montreal
Stay here if you’re coming in winter, or for a game or a festival. Fairmont The Queen Elizabeth is directly above the station.
With children
Old Montreal
The Old Port has the big wheel, the science centre and boat trips. InterContinental Montreal has a pool.
Downtown Montreal
Hotel Bonaventure Montréal has a rooftop garden and a pool, and Warwick Le Crystal has suites.
On a budget
Old Montreal
Hôtel Épik Montréal and Maison Sainte-Thérèse are small places that usually cost less than their neighbours.
Downtown Montreal
Moxy Montreal Downtown, which opened in 2025 behind the station.
A special stay
Old Montreal
Hotel Place d’Armes, four nineteenth-century buildings facing the basilica, with a spa.
Downtown Montreal
Fairmont The Queen Elizabeth, where John Lennon and Yoko Ono held their bed-in in 1969.
Design
Old Montreal
Hotel Nelligan, Hotel William Gray, Hôtel Gault and SonoLux, all with silver medals for Design.
Downtown Montreal
Humaniti Hotel Montreal, a new tower between downtown and Old Montreal.
A winter trip
Old Montreal
Beautiful in the snow, with a skating rink at the port, but you’ll be outdoors between everything.
Downtown Montreal
The easier choice. From Hotel Bonaventure Montréal or Fairmont The Queen Elizabeth you can reach shops, restaurants and the metro without going outside.
Which to choose
Choose Old Montreal if you want charm, good restaurants and a small hotel with stone walls.
It suits a couple’s weekend and a first visit in the warmer months.
Choose downtown if you want a bigger hotel with a pool, or you’re here in deep winter, for hockey or for a festival.
It’s more practical than pretty, and Old Montreal is fifteen minutes’ walk.
Questions
Is it better to stay in Old Montreal or downtown?
Old Montreal for atmosphere, restaurants and small hotels in historic buildings. Downtown for larger hotels with pools, shopping, and shelter from the cold. They’re fifteen minutes apart on foot.
How far is Old Montreal from downtown?
About fifteen minutes on foot, downhill toward the river, or two stops on the metro’s orange line.
Which is better in winter?
Downtown. Several hotels connect directly to the Underground City, so you can get to shops, restaurants and the metro indoors. Old Montreal is lovely under snow, but everything is a walk outside.
Which is better for a first visit?
Old Montreal, in spring, summer or autumn. It’s the most distinctive part of the city and you can walk to downtown. In winter, downtown is easier.
Is Old Montreal walkable?
Yes. It’s about a kilometre from end to end, and the basilica, the port and the main squares are within ten minutes of each other. The streets are cobbled, so wear flat shoes.
Which is quieter at night?
Old Montreal, away from Place Jacques-Cartier. Downtown’s bar streets and the area around the Bell Centre are busy on game nights and at weekends.
Which has hotels with a pool?
Downtown has more: Fairmont The Queen Elizabeth, Hotel Bonaventure Montréal, Humaniti, Warwick Le Crystal and Moxy each have one. In Old Montreal, Hotel William Gray and InterContinental Montreal do.
Which is cheaper?
They’re similar. Old Montreal’s small hotels cost a little more for the setting, and downtown has more large hotels with deals at quiet times.
Where is the Golden Square Mile?
It’s the northern part of downtown, at the foot of Mount Royal, around Sherbrooke Street. The city’s grandest hotels and the fine arts museum are there, and we list its hotels separately from the rest of downtown.
Which is closer to the airport?
Downtown, slightly, and the airport bus stops there. By taxi the difference is a few minutes.