Santorini or Mykonos
Santorini and Mykonos are the two most famous Greek islands, two to three hours apart by ferry in the Cyclades. A lot of people visit both on one trip, and if you have a week that’s the best plan.
If you have to choose, Santorini is the one for views and romance, with hotels cut into a volcanic cliff. Mykonos is the one for beaches and nightlife, with hotels spread around a coast of sandy bays. Both are expensive in summer, and we list about the same number of hotels on each.
Andronis Luxury Suites
“Whitewashed cave labyrinth”
Canaves Epitome
“Dark volcanic villas”
Erosantorini Estate
“Whitewashed clifftop compound”
Grace Hotel
“Cubist cave suites”
Fouquet's Mykonos
“Hushed Cycladic compound”
Kalesma Mykonos
“Cycladic hilltop village”
Mykonos Theoxenia
“Preserved modernist landmark”
Anandes Hotel Mykonos
“Sculpted Mykonian estate”
54
59
1 gold, 24 silver, 28 bronze
8 silver, 49 bronze
Design, Luxe, Local
Design, Luxe, Wellness
47
49
46
58
38
54
On the map
What it’s like
Santorini
Santorini is what’s left of a volcano that blew itself apart 3,600 years ago. The western side of the island is a cliff a thousand feet high, curving around a flooded crater, and the white villages of Oia, Fira and Imerovigli are strung along the top of it.
People come to look: at the view, at the sunset, at each other across a small pool on a terrace. There are black-sand beaches, very good wine and a buried Bronze Age town to visit, but the cliff is the point.
Mykonos
Mykonos is low, dry and ringed with sandy beaches. Its town is a maze of whitewashed lanes that was built to confuse pirates and now confuses everyone, with windmills on the hill and a row of old houses hanging over the sea.
People come to swim, eat a long lunch at a beach club and go out very late. It’s the party island of Greece, though there are quiet corners on the far side for anyone who wants them.
Where the hotels are
Santorini
Almost all are on the caldera cliff. Oia has the most, among them Andronis Luxury Suites, Perivolas Hotel and Katikies Santorini - Pelagos House. Imerovigli, the highest and quietest village, has Grace Hotel and Andronis Concept, and Fira, the capital, has a handful more.
A few are away from the cliff altogether: Istoria Beach is on the black sand of the south coast, and NOŪS Santorini is a larger resort inland.
Mykonos
They’re scattered around the coast. In and above Mykonos Town are Mykonos Theoxenia, a modernist landmark from 1960 beside the windmills, The TownHouse Mykonos and Anandes Hotel Mykonos.
The beach hotels are on the south coast: Santa Marina has a private peninsula at Ornos, Kalesma Mykonos is on the hill above it, and Myconian O is on the sand. On the quieter south-east side are Cali Mykonos and Numo Mykonos.
Getting there and around
Both islands have airports with flights from Athens in under an hour and from much of Europe in summer. Fast ferries run between the two in two to three hours from about April to October. Most hotels on both close for the winter.
Santorini
On Santorini you can stay in one village and walk, and buses from Fira reach the beaches and the ruins. Taxis are scarce, so book transfers ahead.
Mykonos
On Mykonos the hotels, beaches and town are spread out, so you’ll use taxis, the bus or a hired car, and small boats that hop between the southern beaches.
After dark
Santorini
Santorini’s evening is the sunset, then a long dinner with the caldera below. Fira has bars and a few clubs, and Oia goes quiet by eleven.
Mykonos
Mykonos starts late and finishes at sunrise. The beach clubs turn into parties in the afternoon, the bars of the town fill after midnight, and the big clubs go on from there. It’s one of the best-known gay destinations in Europe.
Beaches and things to do
Santorini
The beaches are volcanic, black or red, striking to look at and hot underfoot. The better days out are a boat around the caldera, the cliff walk from Fira to Oia, the wineries, and the excavated town at Akrotiri.
Mykonos
Mykonos has the better beaches by a distance: golden sand and clear water at Ornos, Platis Gialos, Elia and a dozen more. The one sight is a great one, the ruined sacred island of Delos, half an hour away by boat.
By kind of trip
Santorini
Mykonos
A first trip to Greece
Santorini
Choose Santorini for the scenery you’ve seen in pictures. Canaves Ena is at the entrance to Oia.
Mykonos
Choose Mykonos for a beach holiday with a lively town. Mykonos Grand Hotel & Resort is on a beach ten minutes from town.
A honeymoon
Santorini
This is what the island is for. Andronis Luxury Suites holds our gold medal for Luxe, and Grace Hotel in Imerovigli looks straight down into the caldera.
Mykonos
Kalesma Mykonos, a hilltop village of suites with private pools, or Cali Mykonos, above a cove on the quiet side.
With friends
Santorini
Stay near Fira, for the bars. Katikies Garden Santorini is in the old quarter.
Mykonos
The better island for a group. Myconian O is on Ornos beach, and Anandes Hotel Mykonos is a short walk above the town.
With children
Santorini
The cliff villages are all steps and drops. NOŪS Santorini, inland, is a resort with room to move.
Mykonos
Easier, for the sandy beaches. Santa Marina has its own beach on a private headland.
Design
Santorini
Perivolas Hotel, Canaves Epitome and Istoria Beach, all with silver medals for Design.
Mykonos
Mykonos Theoxenia, Numo Mykonos and Fouquet’s Mykonos, all with silver medals for Design.
The beach
Santorini
Istoria Beach and Bellonias Villas are the ones on the sand.
Mykonos
Take your pick. Myconian Utopia Resort is above Elia, and NOMAD Mykonos is near the beach at Kalo Livadi.
Which to choose
Choose Santorini for the view, the sunset and a few days of looking at them.
It suits couples best. Three nights is enough for most people.
Choose Mykonos for beaches by day and a party by night.
It suits groups of friends and anyone who wants to swim every day, and it rewards a longer stay.
Questions
Is Santorini or Mykonos better?
Santorini for scenery, sunsets and romance. Mykonos for beaches, nightlife and a livelier town. If you can’t decide, do both: the ferry between them takes two to three hours.
How far is Mykonos from Santorini?
About 150 kilometres by sea. Fast ferries take two to three hours and run daily from about April to October. There are few direct flights, so the ferry is the usual way.
Which is better for a honeymoon?
Santorini, for most couples. The cliff hotels, with a private terrace and a pool over the caldera, are made for it. Mykonos suits a honeymoon with more beach and more going out.
Which has better beaches?
Mykonos. Its beaches are golden sand with calm, clear water. Santorini’s are black or red volcanic sand, dramatic and less comfortable.
Which is better for nightlife?
Mykonos, by a long way. It has beach clubs, bars and clubs that run until morning. Santorini’s nightlife is mostly in Fira and is much quieter.
Which is more expensive?
Both are among the most expensive islands in Greece in July and August. Hotels cost about the same. Days out cost more on Mykonos, where beach clubs charge a lot for sunbeds and lunch.
How many days do you need on each?
Three nights on Santorini is enough to see the island and enjoy the view. Mykonos is better with four or more, since the point is the beach.
Which is better for families?
Mykonos, for the sandy beaches, if you stay away from the party beaches. Santorini’s cliff villages are hard work with small children, and many cliff hotels don’t take them.
When is the best time to go?
Late May, June and September, when it’s warm, the sea is swimmable and the crowds are thinner. July and August are hot, busy and windy, and most hotels close from November to March.
Which should I visit first?
Either order works. Many people start with the party on Mykonos and finish quietly on Santorini. Check flights home, since both have airports and you needn’t return to Athens.